Main

Guinness World Records acknowledges Sherlock Holmes as the "most portrayed" character in the history of literature. Nearly 100 actors (and one actress so far) have played him in major movie and television productions dating back to the very beginning of the mediums and on stage before that where William Gillette (pictured right) played him so famously that he forever cemented the image of Holmes smoking a calabash pipe in everyone's collective psyche - something he never actually did in Doyle's stories. Fun fact: Holmes never wore a deerstalker in the stories either. Sidney Paget's illustration that accompanied one of Doyle's stories is responsible for that, again, probably cemented in cultural memory by Gillette.

In addition to the original 60 stories written by Arthur Conan Doyle in the late 1800s and early 1900s, there have been countless spin-offs, "lost" tales and pastiches written featuring Holmes and his companion Doctor Watson. With so many works over so many years, it is understandable that the deerstalker and particular design of pipe were not the only details that have become accepted “canon” by many fans of the detective despite the fact that they were not in the original Holmes stories. William S. Baring-Gould is personally responsible for several of them, having written a fictional biography of the character 30 years after Doyle’s death that claims his full name is actually William Sherlock Scott Holmes, he has a second older brother named Sherrinford (the name Doyle was originally going to use before his wife and some publishers convinced him it was terrible) and he had a child with Irene Adler (which the writers of Star Trek used to claim Spock as a distant relative).

Another "fact" from Baring-Gould's book is Sherlock's birthday, which is never mentioned in any of Doyle's stories. He chose January 6 and many fans still acknowledge it. But even more prefer to celebrate May 22, Doyle's birthday, as "Sherlock Holmes Day".

The University of Minnesota boasts the largest collection of Sherlock Holmes and Doyle adjacent works. The collection is searchable but closed, with materials available for use in a special reading room by request. Our library’s collection is nowhere near as comprehensive, but we may be able to get you started if you want to venture into the world of the most famous literary detective.

This guide created by:

Danielle Hoveland

Books

The “Canon”

Due to differences in copyright in several countries, not all editions of Doyle’s complete works actually contain all of the Holmes stories. All of these are available in print in the library in the fiction section (FIC Doyle Arthu) in various combinations. Most of them are available online, though the Case-Book is not included. The complete series is as follows.

A Study in Scarlet 
The first Sherlock Holmes story, often making lists of banned books due to its depiction of the Mormon church.

The Sign of Four 
The second novel, featuring the introduction of Mary, who would become John Watson's wife for a while before disappearing with minimal explanation.

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes 
A collection of 12 short stories, often considered Doyle’s best

Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes
A collection of 11 short stories ending famously with the death of Sherlock after a battle with Professor Moriarty (who only really appeared in this one short story where he had no lines).

The Hound of the Baskervilles 
A novel told in flashback of a case that happened before Sherlock’s death and didn’t feature him much at all. Is often classified as a horror story. 

The Return of Sherlock Holmes 
A collection of 13 short stories reviving Sherlock after ten years and much demand from fans that Doyle take back the whole Reichenbach thing.

The Valley of Fear 
The fourth and last novel, usually considered the weakest of all Holmes stories.

His Last Bow 
A collection of 10 short stories, ending with the outbreak of the first World War.

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes 
A collection of 12 short stories that is sometimes omitted from collected works, both for reasons of copyright and because some people just don't like them and doubt Doyle actually wrote them.
 

Other Sherlock Holmes stories @ DCTC

The Last Sherlock Holmes Story
FIC Dibdi Micha

One of many stories where the famous detective is tapped to assist in solving the famous Jack the Ripper murders. Arthur Conan Doyle was actually tapped to help solve the Ripper murders.
 

The House of Silk and Moriarty
FIC Horrow Antho

One of the more famous series of Sherlock Holmes pastiche.
 

The Disappearance of Sherlock Holmes (MN series)
FIC Mille Larry

This is the sixth installment in Larry Millett’s series, which weaves Sherlock Holmes into Minnesota history.
 

The Beekeeper's Apprentice
FIC King Lauri

A feminist take on Holmes lore with the detective taking on a protégé. The first in a series.



Non-Fiction

Fan Phenomena Sherlock Holmes.
 
 
The Scientific Sherlock Holmes?: Cracking the Case with Science & Forensics


In Bed with Sherlock Holmes Sexual Elements in Arthur Conan Doyle’s Stories of the Great Detective 
 

Movies and Television

In the DCTC Library

Dressed to Kill
The Secret Weapon

These are both from the series of movies starring Basil Rathbone as Sherlock Holmes. Both are largely original stories, though "Secret Weapon" is loosely tied to "The Adventure of the Dancing Men".


The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Ronald Howard (no relation to the director) stars in a 1950s series.


 A Study in Scarlet. 
The Sign of Four

Before Basil, Reginal Owen and Arhur Wotner took a stab at Doyle's first Holmes novels.

 
The Hound of the Baskervilles: Episode 1Episode 2Episode 3Episode 4
 
A BBC miniseries from 1982 starring Tom (The Fourth Doctor) Baker.





Non-Fiction
 

 We Are Legend - Sherlock Holmes Against Conan Doyle
 

How Sherlock Changed the World - Part 1 Part 2

 
The Alternative Sherlock Holmes: Pastiches, Parodies and Copies. 

 

Available from other libraries

Murder by Decree

Another Sherlock Holmes VS Jack the Ripper story


Sherlock Holmes 
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows

Guy Ritchie's modern-ish action movie spin, starring Robert Downey Jr. 


The Great Mouse Detective 

A loose, animated adaptation where "Sherlock" shares a name with his most famous actor: Basil.


Mr. Holmes 

An elderly Holmes retires to Sussex to tend bees.


The Complete Grenada Series (various titles)

The most faithful adaptation of Doyle's works, starring Jeremy Brett.


Sherlock: Season 1, Season 2 and a couple other seasons Holmes fans don't talk about

A modern adaptation starring Doctor Strange and Bilbo Baggins.


Elementary

A modern adaptation set in New York with several character twists